Idaho gets Monta Ellis and Brussels gets Chris Bosh and Nick Young.
So Johnny, who got the better of the deal? I ask this of myself because everyone always wants to know what I think. Is that because of the 7 JBL crowns? Is it because they just want someone else's opinion of their deal? Or is it because I have a blog and could very well write about the trade? Maybe it's a combination of all of them.
OK, I'll break it down. First, I have to look at Idaho's roster to see who else is going to be playing this week in his lineup so we can compare apples to apples. This is ultimately a 2 for 2 trade. So, who is that 2nd player. It appears to be the recently signed Mickael Pietrus. So, lets see how it affects both teams...
Brussels - Timbo got the size he wanted by acquiring Bosh. He also acquired an adequate scorer in Nick Young. Of course, Young's increased production has come while John Wall has been out of the lineup. From Brussels' perspective, I do like this deal. Yes, he loses a lot of steals and a little bit in ATO. However, I see him gaining in most of the other categories.
I'm not sold on Nick Young from a fantasy perspective. Yes, he can score. And he actually shoots a decent FG% and 3PT%. However, I'm not a fan of the rest of his game. How does a Guard have a negative ATO? I don't get that. He also does contribute in steals or blocks and of course he's a weak rebounder. However, anytime you can acquire a 14ppg guy (for now), you do it.
Tim is really challenging himself this season in the JBL. He loves the challenge I sense. Take last week for example, he played with just 10 guys. Now, most of us in the JBL like to go with 12 man active rosters. Not Timmy. He went with 10 by electing to play Terrence Williams and the injured Gerald Wallace. Now, in fairness to Tim, his bench was filled with other guys he's holding out hope can gain (or re-gain) fantasy relevance. He's got Splitter, Troy Murphy and the Birdman all waiting in the wings. Well, none of these guys are good enough right now to help his squad. And in fact, that's why he played G-Wall last week. Because even 1 game from 'Crash' is better than a week's worth of those guys.
Tim is suffering from what I call "keeper-itis" or "don't-want-to-move-on-itis". We all have it. We never want to see a player have success if we drop them. Tim has it with Murphy, Splitter, Terrance Williams, etc. I have it with Roddy Beaubois. Yuma has it with Kelenna Azubuike. We all have those players that we don't want to let go for fear they turn out to be great on someone else's fantasy team. And in most cases, JBL teams stash these players on their injured list. However, most JBL teams have just one of these players. Brussels appears to have several and they are taking up bench spots.
Tim is caught in between "can I still challenge for a money spot" and "I want to have good keepers". It's a difficult place for anyone to be in. My 2 cents - no point in having multiple potential keepers when you're only going to be able to keep 1-2 guys. Enough about Brussels.
Idaho acquired Monta Ellis. Superstud scorer and Mr. Steals himself. I love his fantasy game. I was lucky enough to watch him in Chicago last season when the JBL roadtrip rolled through the Windy City. Why is Monta so great in Fantasy? Because he's a ball hog. Now, don't get me wrong, that's absolute great in terms of Fantasy!
Idaho gets a big time scorer and stealer and also improves slightly in ATO. However, he has lost a lot of rebounds by giving away Bosh. According to a reputable Fantasy basketball analysis website, this trade costs Idaho big time in the rebounds category. And as we all know, rebounds are very tight. Can Idaho keep his current 5th place standing in rebounds? We'll see. Idaho will need K-Mart to help in this category asap.
And what kind of fantasy impact will Mickael Pietrus have?? He had a great game the other night but isn't PHX loaded with guys just like him? Jared Dudley. Grant Hill. Josh Childress. Hakim Warrick. They're all very similar in my books. However, Pietrus does have the advantage, along with Grant Hill, because they play defense.
Pietrus could struggle to find consistent minutes in PHX and his all around fantasy game isn't that impressive. He's another guy who struggles to have a positive ATO. And he certainly isn't a great rebounder. He's a real wild card in the deal and his play (and K-Mart's) will have a big influence on how Idaho did in this trade.
So who won the trade?? Too soon to tell. Starting week 10 Idaho has 906 points and Brussels has 423. Let's see how many points they have in 3-4 weeks. And then we can crown the winner...
So this appears to be the only Pershick-summit trade that went down. I wonder if Arctic was ever in the mix?? Did he have anything brewing? From the sounds of things, Arctic is quite pleased with his Arctic juggernaut at the moment. Crikker is in the ultimate position because he will only do a deal if he wins the trade hands-down. The rest of us have to make 'speculative' trades where we have to risk that a player is going to improve in the coming weeks/months. We should all be jealous of the position the Arctic is currently in.
Anyways, that's all for this morning...